Friday, June 10, 2011

GPL licensed code on the decline

There have been reports that the amount of code written and licensed in copyleft license, that is GNU GPL is on the decline. The entire public network is abuzz with this report. Whoever wrote the report wants to create FUD in the minds of "to be developers" and "contributing communities" regarding GNU GPL. The GNU GPL in my opinion is the most permissive license. It is permissive in the fact that it permits the continuous development of the initial source tree. It is permissive because it permits and paves the way for "not re-inventing the wheel". It is permissive because it permits the basic concept of the existence of human race, sharing and freedom. It is the only license which embodies the concept of freedom and sharing in the same body.

Richard M Stallman has a vision that users, in the near future would be made dumb by making them slaves to proprietary technologies and make every action of users robotic. His prophecy is that "freedom and sharing" as applied to software is the answer to the bullying of big corporations. As the world turns to software for innumerable tasks in human life, freedom and sharing are the human ideologies which would keep the required technology out in the open and approachable to all classes of people. Any future technology developed should be such that they should be based on open standards for the entire human fraternity to repair and upgrade it.

In this crusade of freeing software from the clutches of big corporations, GNU GPL is the open standard which the entire freedom software community should follow. The big corporations are free to package the GPLed software and sell it with improvements(to be given back to the community) to other big corporations. But, individuals, non-profit groups, families also should be self sufficient in computing. This ideological situation is possible if all the freedom developers and in fact, all developers start licensing their code with a GPL V3 and above license developed by the group headed by the visionary Richard M Stallman. His thoughts can be dismissed as completely theoretical and laughed at, but only future will tell what is in store for the computing services users in the near future. Community developers/contributors who give ideas/improvements/code-snippets to freedom software/propreitory software should license their code with GPL v3 and above. This will see to it that these contributions are always available to the "common man" who in the near future is a prospective developer/contributor.

Now, regarding the copyright assignment, I have re-iterated many a times that it is always a better, in fact, the best option to assign the copyright to the free software foundation. The free software foundation is built on very strict ideologies and I am pretty sure that there will not be any dual licensing model as other bigger corporations using freedom software are doing(canonical with ubuntu(future), IBM with websphere(thanx to FAiF podcast for this info) and ....). Assigning copyright ownership of any major code, code snippets, ideas to implement or improve to the big corporations, would lock them up in propreitory black box, thereby stopping further innovation and development and is against sharing and freedom.

I appeal to all the developers and contributors to PLEASE assign copyrights to the free software foundation and license it with GPL v3 and above and make GNU GPL once again, a force to reckon with.

Let the force be with all the freedom developers/contributors/idealists/supporters.

Thursday, May 26, 2011

Response to Mark and copyright freedom projects to FSF

Response to Mark shuttleworth's article http://www.linuxuser.co.uk/opinion/linux-users-ubuntu-column-100-with-mark-shuttleworth/

To start with Mac, sorry, Mark, I think the effort ur team has put for unity is commendable. Why, it is obvious from the passion with which u can go on and on with it. There have been likes and dislikes, features liked and disliked, UI loved and hated and so on… . I am not against anything which will take Free as in Freedom computing to the masses. What I am against, is re-inventing the wheel. G3 developers doing the same thing and the entire canonical paid developers doing the same thing. This is a step back for freedom software.

Ur inspiration were all the propreitory interfaces around the world and not a single idea was borrowed from G3 or other freedom interfaces. That is again a step back.

About the indicators etc.. The less I talk, the better. The whole public network is filled up with this stuff for and against u. I dont want to go on and start whole over. Btw, G3 implemented it better. So u better buckle up.

I really love the way u talk about copyrights. “contributor agreements” is a fantastic way of talking about copyrights, without even hinting at it. I am pretty sure that there will be dual-licensing of all the software u are accumulating copyrights for in the guise of “contributor agreements”. Dont bark at me, now. Time will tell. Can u assign the copyright for all the software u have accumulated to the free software foundation and the licensing of course would be GPL v3 and above?

I, for one would love to increase the meaning of the word "GNU software". There is a generic thinking in the people that GNU software consists of projects "sponsored by FSF". I would say, GNU software is the entire collection of software/creative works out there with the licensing GNU GPL 1 and above. Embracing a GPL license is not enough to protect ur software and the programmers intent. I would appeal to all the freedom programmers to COPYRIGHT their software to the people who stand for "Pure theoritical" freedom. I believe that free software foundation is in a good place to fight for the freedom of the code and its continuity to stay so.
FREEDOM dot

Thursday, May 5, 2011

FSF will do better with more sources of finance

Commercial GNU/Linux, GNU/BSD GNU/Mach distributions(operating systems) are definitely making money. All the vendors are coming out with fancy/experimental front ends to the GNU/* operating systems. They are marketing it as their own OS. Especially Ubuntu. I did not find the word "linux" or "GNU" in a page depth of 2 - 3 on the ubuntu web sit. I am happy with other GNU/* vendors, by at least the fact that they have the name "linux" attached in the name of the product. Ubuntu goes many steps ahead and calls ubuntu, the os. Thats it. Now let us see the attitude of Mark towards the GNU "brand" as he calls it.

My comment on his blog

"Mark, Are u man enough to give an option during install to the users(freedom) to chose between gnome 3.0 and unity *.*?
Do u feel ashamed in calling ur product Ubuntu GNU/Linux?
Dont u think u should thank communities other than U(r)buntu?

btw, congrats on putting out one more experimental shell on the users."

His reply to this was

"@srinivas

I don’t think adding complexity to an install is macho. Do you? By all means, make your own Linux distribution, and add that option. Every Ubuntu user has the easy choice of lots of alternative shells and desktop environments, that’s part of the great thing about Ubuntu. Almost everything is one apt-get away, and if something you care about isn’t, it’s an open environment for your to help others get it too, just step up and participate.

As for your other questions… no, I feel no shame in the fact that Ubuntu is built on GNU and Linux. I also don’t think the people behind those initiatives are so insecure as to feel left out when we don’t put their brand in our brand. You, and every other GNU or Linux fanboy knows exactly what’s GNU and what’s Linux, so there is no benefit to shouting it out. New users who may become contributors to those initiatives will quickly figure it out. And we won’t turn off potential users with a flurry of terminology they don’t understand. All in all, Ubuntu’s track record for bringing new users and contributors to GNU, Linux and Debian is very good. I doubt your whining is much of a help in that regard, but perhaps I’m mistaken and I’d gladly stand corrected if you have facts to back it up.

As for thanking other communities, yes, we do that, all the time in many ways. Lots of those communities work hard to make sure their stuff is fully and properly reflected in Ubuntu as a result. I don’t think you have any point here, other than perhaps to try and be mean and a smart-ass. You succeed admirably on two out of three counts: mean, and an ass.

Mark"

My reply

"@ Mark

Everything is not apt-get away. It has to be brought to that stage by hundreds/thousands of developers. shooing me away by comments which are not “filtered” will not make everything else right.

Come on Mark, Now, who is insecure. U are facing the insecurity of losing new “customers” for ur operating system. As for us “fan boys” we will always fight for “powered by GNU/Linux” label to appear wherever it is used. Suddenly u seem to be upset by the word GNU/Linux. Dont forget that your product aint anything except GNU/Linux unless u develop all the userland and the kernel urself."

Please do continue showing ur “mean” side to the world. I am happy that I have succeeded in exposing that.


I would now like to draw ur attention to this blog http://www.networkworld.com/community/defective-by-design-lacks-traction. It is very clear that FSF's GNU efforts need some traction in terms of cash. I would call upon all the commercial distros to give back to the source. All the commercial distros are taking the source in public domain and in GPL very lightly. They are taking it as granted. They dont want free software evangelists to increase in numbers. They reach this milestone by telling that users are normally dumb and they dont prod deep. If GNU/* is added to the product name, it will create curiosity in the user and will definitely follow the links. This would help FSF enormously in its endeavors.

Saturday, March 26, 2011

All biggies use FLOSS nobody gives back.

Take all the big companies in the IT world. They have used FLOSS in one way or the other. But when it comes to giving back to the same FLOSS projects they act smart. They take out all the loop holes in the FLOSS licensing and use it to shield their proprietary ways. They always resist using software licensed in gpl v3 which is one of the best FLOSS license I have come across to preserve the FLOSS ecosystem. The main reason a FLOSS developer goes for a lesser restrictive license like gpl v2 or bsd/apache license is that proprietary biggies love those licenses and the possibility of its use and reach to users increase. If a developer is interested in vast reach then he would never release it with gpl v3.

The linux kernel is the best example for software licensed with gpl v2. If it was licensed with gpl v3, I dont think google would have put that kernel in android systems. They in turn would have gone for a bsd kernel. Which is the same case with apple. Though linux is far ahead in terms of hardware support compared to bsd kernel, for apple it worked nicely since they are not here to support all the hardware in the world. But for android, it was different. They wanted to support anything and everything on the planet so google went ahead with linux gpl v2. Given the same hardware support or if linux is licensed in gpl v3, I am pretty confident that google will go with bsd kernel. They just have to re-write their virtual machine, and all the apps would run fine.

facebook also uses lot of FLOSS software, but I have not heard about any code being given back to the FLOSS eco-system

The summary is, all these proceeding will stifle further innovations in the FLOSS world and there would not be any special FLOSS project which the biggies can parasite on. I appeal to all the biggies to come out with their usage of FLOSS projects and put the changes and improvements they have done back to the FLOSS ecosystem.

Wednesday, March 16, 2011

RMS and cell phone.

I was getting bored with the heap load of discussions about GNOME, Canonical, Mark Shuttleworth..... Here comes a whiff of fresh air from the Master.

"I don't have a cell phone. I won't carry a cell phone," says Richard. M. Stallman. That is a very serious statement by the founder of Free software foundation. RMS has always been vocal about any technology that invades privacy of people. Let it be the cloud, social networking sites which lack enough privacy extensions or recently the cell phone. RMS is always for absolute freedom. In India Sri Mahatma Gandhi called it "sampoorna" ie, freedom without any tag lines, without any special conditions, without any riders.

Now, what is it with a cell phone. I still have to come across anybody who can make that statement and stand by it. RMS walks his talk. When he was in India a couple of years ago, I read in Linux for you mag that he did not drink packaged water produced by the coca cola company. He waited until he found out a decent source of water not produced by the multinational company. Cell phones can be tracked to the last millimeter. With this we forgo the last millimeter of privacy which is left. The beauty is you will not know that u are being tracked. We do yearn for the good old days where meeting anybody after a long time evoked so much positve happiness among everybody who meets. Now everybody is connected and are normally updated every day/hour/minute by talking over phone or tracking on the social networking sites. Meeting people is these days never exciting. Now that was the "social" problem. RMS does not like the cell phone since it gives immense opportunity for big brother to wait on you, collect enough info on you and then fix you.

Can I live without a cell phone to his standards. No. Partially yes. I would definitely like to increase that "partial" to near complete No. Let us see how much I would succeed. As of now, I do support RMS with his statement regarding cellphones. Will he succeed in changing few others? Difficult.

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

A blog reply to mark shuttleworth

This was the reply sent to mark concerning the revenue sharing model for banshee.

Mark, Please do note the following.
1. Ur explanation of the whole situation is most confusing.
2. U have not taken any stand.
3. Ignorance of law is also a crime. Ignorance of the banshee scenario is no explanation for such a heavily debated topic
4. Banshee or any other "free as in freedom" developers do not need ur advice. They very well know how to make money or not from their favorite project.
5. Your re-iteration of telling the banshee developers to develop "their" project, improve "their" project, think about only "their" projects is something that will not be taken easily by the "free as in freedom" developers.
6. Ubuntu is "your" project. So go ahead and do whatever u want with it.
7. Since u dont like nasty comments here please head out to my blog, If u have time(And if u think that it might give ur monetary returns).
8. "U" and "U"buntu are here at this commanding position because of the "free as in freedom" developers(gnome, linux kernel, open office, kvm, qemu, firefox, X, all the plethora of window managers, GNU/Debian and all the fantastic "free as in freedom" developers.
9. U seem to be interested only in the beatification of GNU/Linux.
10. U have spent only "dollars" in making brand ubuntu known(If allowed, u might have a windows kernel if it was free.)
11. U in fact should have spent those "dollars" in making the world understand "free as in freedom" software.
12. stop aping Apple.

Thursday, February 10, 2011

Debian GNU/Linux testing(nearly squeeze) on Dell M501R

The installation was a succesful one. The installer behaved better than the one coming with ubuntu. The salient points of the journey

1. I downloaded the DVD1 of the testing branch.
2. Booted of the DVD and was presented with myriad of options to start installation. I selected the text based install. (I tried to boot with a ubuntu 10.10 previously, but was unsuccesful. This was owing to the fact that the custom ubuntu kernel was not playing nice with the acpi architecture of my laptop. The kernel option passed was pci=noacpi, which then booted to the live enviroment)
3. Installed the desktop and the laptop options
4. The ati card behaved beautifuly with the open source drivers. Installed xcompmgr and composition was provided for docky and gnome-do.
5. Broadcom drivers had to be compiled from source. More about this in a previous post.
6. Tried to install the liquorix kernel using synaptic. It screwed up my graphics drivers. Purged the graphics driver and booted back to the debian kernel.
7. Compiled the liquorix kernel manually with liquorix configs. Then installed the propreitory drivers from ati, followed by re-installing xcompmgr for composition.
8. Re-compile the broadcom drivers for the new kernel
9. Configured docky to look similar to the layout in pinguy os.
10. Installed mplayer-mt for the 3-core amd phenom
11. Installed pidgin.(Empathy started crashing after few updates)
12. Installed chrome browser
13. Installed KDE full.
14. Failed to run compiz

Update 18.02.2011:

Empathy(11) and compiz(14) started working after updating the ati propreitory drivers to v 11.2


Thanks to the Debian GNU/Linux team and congratulations on a great release.